A couple of years ago I put a LumaFix64 into my PAL C64 and I was quite happy with the results, using a Sony PVM CRT monitor. You can read about that here. It does a good job of virtually eliminating those “jailbars” from the VIC-II output.
But lately, I am not using CRT displays any more, mainly because I just don’t want to devote the real estate to keeping them out. Instead, I’ve been using a RetroTINK 2X-Pro to scale the s-video (via Commodore4Ever AV Breakout) output from my C64s to HDMI.
I decided to add a LumaFIX to one of my NTSC units and do some actual comparisons. I already knew I was happy with what it does for the picture quality on a CRT monitor, but is it worthwhile when using an HD display through a RetroTINK? Here’s the video:
Note: it may be hard to see the jailbar effect clearly if you’re not viewing the 1080p stream.
My conclusion: The LumaFix64 does a good job of removing the jailbar effect from the video, but at the cost of sharpness that I do not find acceptable for my HDMI display.
You can download the little color program I wrote here: jail.d64
Here are the before and after screens shown in the video. Click for the full-size PNGs.
And a close-up of the LumaFixed output on my Sony PVM CRT:
LumaFix is sharp for me. Dell FP2001 via Svideo.